- Named FWAA First-Year Head Coach of the Year
- Posted a 10-3 mark in his first season as head coach, only WVU coach to win 10 games in his first year
- Led West Virginia to Big East Championship and BCS win, first WVU coach to accomplish that feat
- Earned national rankings in 13-of-16 weeks of 2011 season in both the AP and USA Today Coaches Polls reaching as high as No. 11 in the AP Poll and tied for No. 14 in the USA Today Coaches Poll
- Tied for fourth in wins among first-year head coaches nationally
- One of seven coaches to take his program to a BCS Bowl in his first year as a head coach, and only one of three (Larry Coker, 2001; Chris Peterson, 2007) to win the bowl game.
- Fourth WVU coach to make a bowl appearance and win in his first season (Bill Stewart, Dudley DeGroot, Marshall Glenn)
- Three Mountaineer players earned seven All-America honors
- Three Mountaineer players drafted in the NFL Draft, including the No. 15 pick, Bruce Irvin
- WVU led the BIG EAST with 10 all-conference honorees and the Special Teams Player of the Year, Austin
- WVU finished No. 6 nationally in passing offense, No. 13 in scoring offense and No. 15 in total offense.
- The Mountaineer offense ranked No. 67 in total offense in 2010, the year before Holgorsen arrived, and he took it to No. 15 in 2011.
- In 2011, Austin and Bailey were the fourth pair of 1,000-yard receivers nationally (Houston, USC, SMU).
- WVU was one of two schools nationally to have a 4,000-yard passer and two 1,000-yard receivers (Houston).
- Quarterback Geno Smith finished No. 5 nationally in passing yards per game, No. 8 in completions per game and total offense and No. 17 in passing efficiency.
- Austin finished No. 1 nationally in all-purpose yardage (198.0), No. 6 in punt returns, No. 8 in receptions per game, No. 20 in kickoff returns and No. 23 in receiving yards per game.
- Bailey finished No. 13 nationally in receiving yards per game.
- In 2010, was named a finalist for the Frank Broyles Award, signifying the top assistant coach in college football and named the rivals.com national offensive coordinator of the year
- In 2010, the Cowboys led the nation in total offense during the regular season and finished No. 2 in passing offense and No. 3 in total and scoring offense.
- OSU averaged 520.23 yards per game in total offense, including 345.9 passing yards and 44.23 points per game.
- The Cowboy offense ranked No. 61 nationally in total offense in 2009, the year before Holgorsen arrived, and he took it to the No. 1 spot in 2010.
- Quarterback Brandon Weeden became the first OSU passer to earn first team all-Big 12 honors. He was a finalist for the Manning Award, given to the top quarterback in the nation.
- Receiver Justin Blackmon was named the recipient of the 2010 Biletnikoff Award, given to the top receiver in the nation, and running back Kendall Hunter was a finalist for the Doak Walker Award, given to the nation's top running back.
- Weeden, Hunter and Blackmon became only the second trio in NCAA history to pass for at least 3,000 yards, run for more than 1,500 yards and finish with more than 1,500 yards receiving in the same season.
- In 2009, UH led the nation in total offense with 563 yards per game, scoring offense with 42.2 points per game, and passing offense with 433.7 yards per game.
- In 2008, his first year at Houston, the Cougars ranked second in the nation in passing offense (401.6) and total offense (562.77). UH scored 40.62 points per game to rank 10th nationally.
- Houston quarterback Case Keenum led the nation in total offense in 2008 and 2009, with 403.15 yards of total offense per game as a sophomore and 416.36 yards of offense as a junior.
- Keenum ranked among the nation's top-10 passing efficiency leaders each of his two seasons under Holgorsen's watch.
- During his tenure as offensive coordinator, the Red Raiders increased their offensive numbers from 324.8 yards per game to 529.6 yards per game.
- In 2007, Texas Tech led the nation in passing offense (470.31 yards per game), ranked second in total offense (529.62 yards per game) and was seventh in scoring offense (40.92 points per game).
- Quarterback Graham Harrell led the nation in total offense and receiver Michael Crabtree led the nation in receptions per game and receiving yards per game. Crabtree won the Biletnikoff Award as America's top receiver in 2007.
- In 2006, the Red Raiders ranked third nationally in passing offense and sixth in total offense. Harrell was third nationally in total offense with 344.38 yards per game.
- In 2005, Texas Tech led the nation in passing offense with 388.83 yards per game, was fourth in scoring offense at 39.42 points per game and was sixth in total offense with 495.83 yards per contest.
- Quarterback Cody Hodges ranked second in the country with 369.08 yards per game.
- Coached Lucas Greene who led the team in scoring that season and went on to play in the NFL
- Mississippi College won the American Southwest Conference in its first season in the league and averaged 432.0 yards per game in 1997.
- Helped develop quarterback Chris Hatcher, who set an NCAA record, completing 74.7 percent of his passes on the Division II level in 1994.
- Hatcher's 10,588 passing yards ranked third on the NCAA career list at the time.
- Hatcher currently ranks second in the NCAA record books in career touchdown passes (116) and third in single-season touchdown passes (50 in 1994) and was the NCAA passing champion in 1994.
- Three-year letterwinner
- Finished career as No. 5 all-time receiver in school history with 1,711 yards
- Finished career as No. 6 all-time receiver in receptions with 145